What an electric hot water cylinder costs to run in NZ
A hot water cylinder is the quietest large load in a New Zealand house. There is no switch, no thermostat on the wall, nothing that makes a noise - just a tank in a cupboard that has been keeping water hot since before you moved in. It is typically 25-30% of an annual power bill, second only to heating, and most people have no idea what it costs them.
For a two-person household the answer is about $334 a year. That is lower than most people guess, and the reason why turns out to be the most useful thing on this page.
Cost scales with people, not with wattage
Nearly every other appliance in a house costs what it costs because of its power rating and how many hours it runs. A cylinder does not work like that. The element might be 3 kW, but it only draws power while reheating the tank, and how often it needs to do that depends almost entirely on how much hot water leaves the building - showers, laundry, dishes. EECA's working figure is about 2.1 kWh per person per day, and that scales close to linearly:
| Household | Electric cylinder | Hot water heat pump | Saved per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 person | $167 | $56 | $111 |
| 2 people | $334 | $111 | $223 |
| 3 people | $501 | $167 | $334 |
| 4 people | $668 | $223 | $446 |
| 5 people | $835 | $278 | $557 |
| 6 people | $1,003 | $334 | $668 |
That linearity is why a flatting household of five notices hot water on the bill and a retired couple often does not. It is also why the standard advice to "take shorter showers" is better targeted at large households than small ones - there is simply more of it to save.
The overnight discount you may already be getting
Most New Zealand cylinders sit on ripple control. The local lines company broadcasts a signal that switches domestic hot water on overnight, when national demand and wholesale prices are at their lowest, and the tank - which is a large, well-insulated thermos - holds that heat through the following day. In exchange you get a controlled or night rate on that circuit, here 21.8c/kWh against a day rate of 36.3c.
Every figure on this page assumes you have that. If your cylinder is billed at the full day rate - which happens on some plans, and on some newer installs where the controlled circuit was never wired up - your real cost is roughly two-thirds higher than the table above. Before doing anything else with hot water, it is worth finding out which of those two situations you are in. It is the single largest swing available, it costs nothing to check, and it is invisible unless you go looking at your invoice.
Standing loss: the bath nobody takes
The other half of the cost is not water you use at all. A tank held at temperature leaks heat into the cupboard continuously, and the element reheats to replace it. Go away for a long weekend and the cylinder keeps working the whole time, maintaining a tank of hot water for a household that is four hundred kilometres away.
This is the part you can attack without changing anyone's habits:
- Fit a cylinder wrap and lag the first metre of outlet pipe. One-off, under $100, and it works every day thereafter. The gain is largest on older tanks; modern cylinders have far better factory insulation and less to reclaim.
- Set the thermostat to 60°C - and not lower. Below 60°C the tank becomes a viable environment for Legionella. If you want cooler water at the tap, fit a tempering valve, which mixes it down after it leaves a cylinder that is still stored safely hot.
Together those two changes typically take 10-15% off this load. On the four-person figure of $668 that is roughly $84 a year for an afternoon's work.
When a heat pump actually pays back
A hot water heat pump uses roughly a third of the energy to deliver the same hot water, and the saving column above is real money. But the payback maths is more particular than it is usually presented, because it depends entirely on when you ask the question.
If your cylinder is working fine and you are considering replacing it early, you are spending the full installed price of about $4,500 to buy that saving. For a two-person household that is a payback of around 20 years - longer than the unit's expected life. It does not stack up.
If your cylinder has just died, the question changes completely. You are buying something regardless, and a replacement electric cylinder is about $2,000 of that cost anyway. The real decision is the price difference of roughly $2,500, and against that:
| Household | Saved per year | Replacing a dead cylinder | Replacing a working one |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 person | $111 | 22 yrs | 40 yrs |
| 2 people | $223 | 11 yrs | 20 yrs |
| 3 people | $334 | 7 yrs | 13 yrs |
| 4 people | $446 | 6 yrs | 10 yrs |
| 5 people | $557 | 4 yrs | 8 yrs |
| 6 people | $668 | 4 yrs | 7 yrs |
Read down that third column and the rule of thumb writes itself: wait until the cylinder fails, then upgrade - especially in a larger household, where the difference pays for itself several times over across the unit's roughly fifteen-year life. Our longer cylinder versus heat pump comparison works through the rest of the decision, including the cases where a heat pump is the wrong answer.
One caveat on the numbers above: they assume the existing cylinder is already on a night rate, which is the harshest possible test for the upgrade. A household paying the day rate for hot water saves considerably more by switching, and pays back proportionally faster.
The order to do things in
Hot water rewards being tackled in the right sequence, and the cheapest steps come first:
- Check the tariff. Free. Potentially the largest single change on this page.
- Wrap the tank, lag the pipe, set 60°C. Under $100, 10-15% off, permanent.
- Reduce the hot water you use. Shorter showers, cold washes. Scales with household size, so most worthwhile in a full house.
- Replace with a heat pump - when the old one dies. Excellent on the price difference, poor on the full price.
To put your own household size and your own rate against these figures rather than the national averages, open the calculator - the hot water row takes a people count directly. If you want to see where hot water sits against everything else in the house, the full appliance table ranks all 45.